image map Home Favorites Reading About Contact

I thought I understood

John.5-39

Yet you refuse to come to me that you may have life.
John 5:39-40

I thought I understood.
But now?

When I was growing up, some in my religious group thought they had the Bible all figured out. Okay, we thought we had it all figured out (ouch).

We had our reasons.

When I asked myself why we were among the lucky few to get it right, I came up with three possibilities (this pains me to admit, just so you know).

Take your pick:

  • Possibility # 1: Brains
    Maybe we were just smarter than everyone else. Scriptures that might confuse others made perfect sense to us. We could explain them so logically AND even include cross-references. We considered ourselves blessed with doctrinal accuracy.
  • Possibility # 2: Discipline
    Or possibly we understood more because we studied more than everyone else. We took time to meticulously analyze each scripture, each Greek or Hebrew word, each church-approved commentary. Our effort made the difference.
  • Possibility # 3: Sincerity
    Or maybe we were the only ones who honestly wanted to know God’s Word. Maybe everyone else just tricked themselves (consciously or subconsciously) into believing the Bible said what they wanted it to say. They could toss out hard parts that made them uncomfortable, whereas we wanted to take all of God’s Word and obey it because we cared more about Truth than everyone else.

Oh, my.
(If you’re repulsed by me now, I understand. I’m kinda sick, too.)

But as I got older, my hypotheses of why we were always right and everyone else was wrong began to crack.

It particularly got shaky when . . .

  • I started reading books by other smart men and women . . . outside of my tribe. They made equally intelligent and logical arguments that opposed some of the traditional interpretations I’d always held. How could this be?
  • And I discovered people with differing opinions who had pledged their entire careers to studying the Word, far more in-depth than anyone I’d personally met. No lack of dedication to scholarship there.
  • And the final kicker: I made friends with believers from other denominations who really did care about pleasing God and who were living all out to love Jesus and love others at great personal sacrifice.

These people quoted the same scriptures I did; they prayed for others like I did; they talked about God like I did (well, I’m fudging; actually they talked far more about God than I did because I was talking more about church and the Bible, less about God, Jesus, and certainly less about the Spirit).

Perhaps, just maybe, I and my friends weren’t the only true believers after all?

Aha!  

So now I hold my interpretations with a looser grip. Not on the fundamentals (and my collection of fundamentals has shrunk drastically), but my conclusions on the gray areas are open for discussion.

I’m okay if you and I don’t believe the exact same thing. It doesn’t necessarily mean one of us is smarter or more studied or more sincere than the other.

And it doesn’t mean I’m a Christian and you are not. Or vice versa.

I’ve discovered that:

No one is brainy enough or disciplined enough or caring enough to understand it all, no matter how intelligent they are or how much they study or how devout they are. 

Being smart won’t save you.
Being correct won’t save you.
Being sincere won’t save you.

Jesus saves you.
This I know.

That doesn’t mean we should forget about thinking things through, or stop all spiritual disciplines, or drop our desire to love deeper. But it does mean we realize those are gifts of grace to exercise, not debts to repay or workouts to legalistically perform.

Am I ashamed at how I used to believe, at how I used to judge others? Embarrassingly so.

But I’m more excited to trade away attempting to get everything right by my own efforts, and instead accept the free gift of salvation based on Jesus’ 100% righteousness.

I want to continue growing closer to TruthJesus.
He’s the only one who knows it all,
has finished it all,
and loves us all. Perfectly.

Now I understand:
He is right. He is enough.

Truly, truly, I say to you, whoever hears my word and believes him who sent me has eternal life. He does not come into judgment, but has passed from death to life.
John 5:24

And you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free.
John 8:32

* * *

Have you ever changed your mind about what you believe?

Has it brought you more peace and rest, too?

Comments (34)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
You're welcome, Hazel.

Change can be so good sometimes, yes? I'm thankful we've discovered Christians in many places. It makes for a richer life.
My recent post I thought I understood
I think if your theology doesn't change and grow as you grow and come to know God and His word more then you're in trouble. There have been some major shifts in my thinking in lots of areas over the years. In fact, we made a very personally costly decision to leave the denomination that my Hubs was a third generation member of and an ordained minister in for 20+ years, because our understanding of some things grew and changed. I think we too often place God in a very small box of our own understanding. The important thing to remember is that our "I thinks" don't really matter, it's what He thinks and has communicated through His Word that must be the plumb line.
My recent post Autumn mantel...
1 reply · active 654 weeks ago
Exactly, Elizabeth. If our theology never changes, we're not growing, because who starts out with a mature theology? I can imagine your decision to leave your heritage was a very heavy one. That's how we've felt ourselves. Still in process. But along with the pain, I also feel great freedom and peace in our decision. God is being faithful--he always is. I know you know that and experience it daily too.
My recent post I thought I understood
smiles...i think you got that right...none of us has it fully figured out and in expanding our view through the reading of others we may settle in a place that is comfortable but then again someone will come along and challenge that as well...i figure as long as we have the fundamentals...love being the key and that made perfect in the one that brought it to us in the most raw form...we are on the right path....i know nothing, but i do know someone...smiles.
My recent post OpenLinkNight: thrU seasons
1 reply · active 654 weeks ago
"but I do know someone"
That's it, Brian. It's who we know that matters.
My recent post I thought I understood
Having gone to a Christian college, I know just what you mean:) Self-righeousness reigned for me there. I've been on a similar journey and have loved meeting people from all backgrounds who share the same love for God. This is such a great post and important one too. Blessings!
My recent post To Walk Alongside the Hurting
1 reply · active 654 weeks ago
Thanks, Christina. Yes, it sounds like you do know. The sin of self-righteousness is such a sneaky one. Like the virtue of humility. If you think you don't have it, you probably do. :-)
My recent post I thought I understood
I loved your post, Lisa. I think as one matures spiritually, we realize that spiritual disciplines are "gifts of grace to exercise, not debts to repay or workouts to legalistically perform." (You said that so beautifully!)

Isn't it wonderful that as we grow we realize there is more to learn? How boring if we really thought we knew everything and had attained it all?
My recent post Are You Just a Stone's Throw Away?
1 reply · active 654 weeks ago
Yes, it would be boring if we reached the ceiling of knowledge and had nothing left to learn. Not a chance of that happening though. ha. I do love to learn; I hope I never grow tired of it. Thanks for your part in teaching me (I just took care of what I should have done yesterday, thanks to you.)

My recent post I thought I understood
I've been down similar roads, God is always stretching us to show us His ways our higher than our ways and when we think we have Him all figured out He reveals even more of Himself.
My recent post Perseverance
1 reply · active 654 weeks ago
I'm sure God gets quite a few chuckles when he sees us thinking we have things figured out down here. ;-) So thankful that he's so patient with us and is willing to stretch us in all the right places.
My recent post I thought I understood
I went through a similar journey, except that I didn't grow up all in one church. I went back and forth between two denominations until my mid-teens. One taught we needed to have faith in God in a nebulous sense, the other spoke of a personal need to repent of sins and accept Christ as Savior. I thought since the latter was right on that issue, they were right on everything else. :-)

When we moved to a new city and a church that was in the same denomination but had some very different standards, I was distressed and had to take some time with a notebook and Romans 14 and hammer some things out. I finally came to peace that people could differ on some of these issues that weren't spelled out in Scripture and both still love God and fellowship with each other.

But then, further, like you, I found people who differed with me on what I thought were clear passages of Scripture. I've often pondered how two people (or groups of people) who both love God and want to serve Him and live for Him in ways that please Him can come to such different conclusions on what His Word says. I still don't know. I don't think those things don't matter any more -- I am still responsible before God to study His Word and seek His guidance and live and practice according to what I feel His Word teaches. But as you said, I'm not to call into question the other person's salvation or love for God just because they come to a conclusion on things outside of the fundamental truths of who Jesus is, how a person is saved, the verity of the Bible, etc.
My recent post “As seen on the Internet”
1 reply · active 654 weeks ago
I still don't know either, Barbara--how smart and sincere believers can view the same scripture in different ways. But, yes, we do see it all the time, Just trusting God to work through it with each of us. Thankful for grace!

Thanks for sharing this part of your church story. It's helpful to me to hear other people surviving and thriving through similar struggles. There really is nothing new under the sun.
My recent post I thought I understood
I really appreciate your honesty and openness here, Lisa. Most of us won't admit it. I too spent many years judging others through legalistic means, which meant that I missed the essence of the heart of God far more than just misinterpreting a verse or verses in the Bible.

I've also changed my mind about several of the key issues that really divide us as Christians. I never share them on my site because I feel God is calling us to unite, not bicker over smaller issues that the enemy uses to divide and conquer us. I've done several Bible studies with other people over divisive issues with the right perspective and it is truly freeing. Only once have I actually spent time in discussion about the subject. God called me to let it go, to hang onto it for me... For me and Him... For the honor of the time spent in studying and seeking Him. After all, isn't that what it's all about?

We are called to come together and show the world who we are by how we treat each other, "The world will know you belong to me by the love you show to one another," (paraphrase from memory... and yeah, I know it's not as good as yours!)

I don't care so much about on the things we don't agree, I'm lifted up by coming together with you and all my fellow brothers and sisters in Christ and affirming what we do know without question...
My recent post INSANITY
1 reply · active 653 weeks ago
I want to add an "Amen" at the end of every one of your statements, Floyd. We're definitely on the same page. I'm glad that God doesn't leave us in our legalism, but continues to help draw us out. I wonder what I'm being legalistic about even now and am just not aware of it. God will reveal it in time....
Oh, yes, Lisa. You could have written this post about me. I've long known what I know, and could argue someone into a corner theologically and make them cry (and I'm not saying I haven't) I've always thought it was important to be right about God as he revealed himself to be.

I have an elderly aunt whose theology is pretty black and white, so I was surprised one day when she said, "Who knows, when we get to heaven, how much we'll find out we were wrong about?" It was so very humbling.

Yes, I've met good and faithful people whose theology doesn't line up with mine. I'm getting better at living with paradox, and trusting that God is perfectly capable of bringing even clanging gongs and noisy cymbals like me into a deeper understanding of him.

The only thing that matters, Paul wrote, is faith expressing itself in love.
My recent post Falling in Love With a Picture
1 reply · active 653 weeks ago
I'm feeling more camaraderie than I expected with this post. Don't know if that's good or bad that so many of us once were legalistic. ha. It's definitely good that we're coming around though. Love the question by your aunt; we're never too old to change.

"getting better at living with paradox" - great way to put it!
Your clarity and honesty never ceases to amaze me, sister. I'm right there with ya! And you know why ...
My recent post A Beautiful Thing
1 reply · active 653 weeks ago
Yep, I know you hear me, Lori. ;-) We're cut from the same cloth. Love you.
A big heart-felt AMEN! I am right with you. Such a WONDERFUL post: open, honest, vulnerable, sincere, loving and, most of all, pointing to Jesus! Rock on, sis! Abundant blessings!
My recent post Upright Living Yields Fruit
1 reply · active 653 weeks ago
Thanks, Mari-Anna. I appreciate your encouragement...sometimes we write posts and hit "publish" tentatively, so it's nice to get affirmation that others understand what we're trying to say.

Pointing to Jesus--I'm sure I flub that up a lot, but it is my heart's goal. Blessings back to you.
Oh been there done that! I grew up in a similar milieu of friends :) Actually, though, I've spent years coming to grips with the same concerns about Islam and my Muslim friends. A huge challenge to hold on tightly to my own faith when I have so much respect for how they do their faith. I do it just because I know I need Jesus in my life and that has to be enough.
My recent post I dreamed about Bashar al-Asad last night, but can’t remember if he was a good guy or a bad guy
1 reply · active 653 weeks ago
With your travels, I'm sure you've had to drop legalistic thinking long ago and in ways I still haven't even thought of. I'm always interested in what you share, Kati. Thanks for your honesty. You show me things I can't see on my own.
You and I experienced the very same things! And God stretches us to think outside of our little box, and it is very good! He is on the throne, not me and my opinions, hallelujah!
My recent post You don’t get a Vote
1 reply · active 653 weeks ago
I admit there are days I'd like to have my own little throne. ha. But everyone should be thankful I don't have one. It wouldn't be pretty. :-)

Yes, God DOES stretch us and even though it may hurt at the time, it's always good.
nope, not repulsed at all. i'm compelled by your honesty and admiring of the humility of your journey. this is grace and truth.
1 reply · active 653 weeks ago
Thank you...it's nice to have others who are understanding along this journey. Blessings to you.
Jesus saves us. This is a post written directly to me. Sure, it's a good thing to know the bible. It's a good thing to understand doctrine. But it is essential to know Jesus and put your faith in him. Critical knowledge is knowing Jesus.
1 reply · active 653 weeks ago
Exactly, exactly! "Critical knowledge is knowing Jesus." Wish I'd said that myself.
Amy Nabors's avatar

Amy Nabors · 653 weeks ago

Oh yes. So many of the beliefs I grew up being taught don't line up with what God has taught me over the past several years. It's not us vs. them any longer. For me, it came down to heart attitude. Once I gave up trying to be "good enough" I realized He was enough. And if He is enough for me then He is for those who don't believe exactly as I do. Sufficient has been my "one word" for 2012 and He has taught me that He is sufficient for all no matter if I agree with them or not, and it is not my job or responsibility to change them. Great post, Lisa!
My recent post Hummingbird
1 reply · active 653 weeks ago
I thought you might relate to this. That whole "us vs them" mentality is definitely something that has to be resolved in order to have truly transformed hearts (and I'm not saying I've officially arrived there myself, but I'm on the right road).

Not only is He sufficient for us, but He's sufficient for everybody else too. Thanks for sharing that insight. (Sufficient is such a great "one word" choice, btw.)
My recent post How can I love God more?
Lisa - As always, awesome. I so appreciate your thoughts here, and I can identify! I'm slowly learning not to pride in knowledge, but just. lean. on. Him!! And take pride in Him.
My recent post Book Review: Running for My Life by Lopez Lomong
1 reply · active 653 weeks ago
Take pride in him! Yes. That's what we're specifically told to do:

"So that, as it is written, “Let the one who boasts, boast in the Lord.”
1 Corinthians 1:31

Thanks, Caroline.
My recent post Why these books? - Fall 2012 reading list

Post a new comment

Comments by

LinkWithin

Related Posts with Thumbnails